§ V.01What a Ferrari 458 is worth
A Ferrari 458 built between 2009 and 2015 sells for a median of $250,000 as of 1 November 2026, based on 237 completed auction sales.
The middle half of those 237 sales fell between $191,000 and $369,900 (the typical range), and the full range after cleaning was $103,000 to $2,425,000.
Data as of 1 November 2026 · 237 sales · June 2016 to 25 October 2026 · auction results only
§ V.02What moves a car within the band
Within that band, convertible cars are the most frequently traded body style in this set (100 of 237 sales), and automatic cars account for 138 of them. Condition, originality and documented history move a car further than any single specification, which is why the middle half of the range is wide.
The spread by variant, printed in full above, is usually wider than the spread by year: a convertible at $264,250 and a coupe at $211,000 are not the same market, and a single median that mixes them describes neither.
§ V.03Recent sales
| Car | Sold for | Date | Mileage | Sold by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2013 Ferrari 458 Spider | $257,458 | 25 October 2026 | 35,000 mi | Bring a Trailer |
| 10k-Mile 2012 Ferrari 458 Spider | $290,000 | 21 October 2026 | 10,000 mi | Bring a Trailer |
| 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia | $250,000 | 15 October 2026 | 33,000 mi | Bring a Trailer |
| 16k-Kilometer 2014 Ferrari 458 Spider | $410,000 | 14 October 2026 | 16,000 km | Bring a Trailer |
| 2,400-Mile 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia | $440,000 | 12 October 2026 | 2,400 mi | Bring a Trailer |
| 2015 Ferrari 458 Speciale | $519,000 | 9 October 2026 | 17,734 km | Collecting Cars |
| 2015 Ferrari 458 Speciale | $1,016,500 | 1 October 2026 | 10,000 mi | Bring a Trailer |
| 2012 Ferrari 458 Challenge | $153,000 | 26 September 2026 | 49,000 mi | Bring a Trailer |
| 9k-Mile 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia | $341,000 | 24 September 2026 | 9,000 mi | Bring a Trailer |
| 7k-Mile 2013 Ferrari 458 Spider | $459,999 | 23 September 2026 | 7,000 mi | Bring a Trailer |
| 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia | $234,117 | 21 September 2026 | 40,000 mi | Bring a Trailer |
| 7k-Mile 2013 Ferrari 458 Spider | $500,000 | 5 September 2026 | 7,000 mi | Bring a Trailer |
| 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia | $300,000 | 3 September 2026 | 19,198 mi | Sothebysmotorsport |
| 7k-Mile 2013 Ferrari 458 Spider | $425,000 | 29 August 2026 | 7,000 mi | Bring a Trailer |
| 2013 Ferrari 458 Spider | $400,058 | 28 August 2026 | 20,000 mi | Bring a Trailer |
§ V.04Price by model year
| Model year | Median | Sales |
|---|---|---|
| 2010 | $172,750 | 18 |
| 2011 | $194,250 | 34 |
| 2012 | $217,618 | 30 |
| 2013 | $245,000 | 53 |
| 2014 | $255,800 | 42 |
| 2015 | $496,250 | 60 |
§ V.05Price by body style and transmission
| Variant | Type | Median | Sales |
|---|---|---|---|
| Convertible | Body style | $264,250 | 100 |
| Coupe | Body style | $211,000 | 94 |
| Automatic | Transmission | $235,622 | 138 |
§ V.06Questions
What is a Ferrari 458 2009-2015 worth?
A Ferrari 458 built between 2009 and 2015 sells for a median of $250,000 as of 1 November 2026, based on 237 completed auction sales.
The middle half of those 237 sales fell between $191,000 and $369,900 (the typical range), and the full range after cleaning was $103,000 to $2,425,000.
How many Ferrari 458 sales is that based on?
237 completed auction sales, from June 2016 to 25 October 2026. The table above lists the 15 most recent, each linked to its auction record. The figures were last rebuilt on 1 November 2026.
What is the difference between the typical range and the full range?
The typical range is $191,000 to $369,900: half of all 237 sales fell inside it. The full range is $103,000 to $2,425,000, the cheapest and dearest sale that survived cleaning. The full range is set by outliers, so it is a boundary rather than a guide to what most cars bring.
Which body style holds its value best?
On this set, convertible is the most frequently sold at 100 sales with a median of $264,250. The highest median among body styles is convertible at $264,250, though it rests on fewer sales. Each variant's median and count are in the table above.
Do manual or automatic cars sell for more?
In this set, automatic cars account for 138 of 237 sales. Too few cars of the other transmission type sold to publish a comparison, so this page does not make one.
Does mileage change the value?
Mileage is recorded for part of this set, not all of it, so it is not used to adjust the median. It is shown in the sales table wherever the auction record carries it, and you can see the effect directly by comparing rows.
Why is a Ferrari 458 worth more than the median?
Condition, originality and documented history move a car further than any single specification, which is why the middle half of the range is wide.
How current is this figure?
Data as of . The figures are rebuilt from completed sales on a schedule, and the date above is the date of the last rebuild, not the date this page was loaded.
§ V.07Method and sources
What these figures are. Every number on this page is computed from completed auction sales of Ferrari 458 cars built between 2009 and 2015. The median is the 50th percentile of the sale prices; the typical range is the 25th to 75th percentile; the full range is the lowest and highest sale that survived cleaning. Percentiles are linearly interpolated on the sorted prices.
What is excluded. Asking prices, reserve-not-met results, withdrawn lots and unsold cars are not prices and are not counted. Parts, memorabilia, literature, scale models and other non-vehicle lots are excluded. Sales not made in US dollars are excluded, so these figures describe the dollar market. Duplicate records are removed. Sales below a plausibility floor (5% of the median) and above a ceiling (10× the median) are set aside, because a $22 "911" is a data error rather than a cheap car.
What it is not. This is not an appraisal or an inspection, and it does not predict what any particular car will bring. Two cars built the same year can differ by more than the whole typical range on condition, originality, documentation and provenance.
The set. 237 sales from June 2016 to 25 October 2026, drawn from 10 auction sources, principally Bring a Trailer (154), Barrett-Jackson (18), RM Sotheby's (16), Cars & Bids (13), Collecting Cars (10), Gooding (8), PCARMARKET (5), Sothebysmotorsport (5), Bonhams (4), Broad Arrow (4). Data as of .
See the disclaimer for the limits of a valuation of this kind.
§ V.08Compare with
- Ferrari 355 1994-1999 — $101,000 median · 428 sales · as of 1 November 2026
- Ferrari F40 1987-1992 — $2,440,444 median · 41 sales · as of 1 November 2026
- BMW E9 1968-1975 — $66,000 median · 278 sales · as of 1 November 2026
Value a specific car with a full report
This page is the market. A report is the car: paste the listing and BidBetter returns a bid target, a likely range and a walk-away number for that specific vehicle.
Value a specific car →